Haunted Hotels in Garberville
Tucked deep within California’s towering redwood forests, Garberville is a small Humboldt County town known for its rustic charm and peaceful natural beauty. But behind its tranquil atmosphere lies an air of mystery that lingers in the old inns and historic buildings scattered throughout the area.
Once a stopover for weary travelers and loggers making their way through the redwoods, Garberville holds stories that blur the line between history and haunting. Visitors often report strange chills and flickering lights in one of the town’s oldest hotels, a reminder that even in the calm of the forest, the past is never far away.
Haunted stay options in Garberville, CA
Benbow Historic Inn
Address: 445 Lake Benbow Dr, Garberville, CA 95542
Phone: (707) 923-2124
Website: benbowinn.com
Price Range: Average rate: $200–$350 per night.
Notable Paranormal Signs: Apparition of a woman in white, objects moving on their own, electrical malfunctions, a broken clock chiming, and figures seen in locked rooms.
History and Hauntings:
Opened in 1926 by the Benbow family, this Tudor-style inn was designed by architect Albert Farr as a luxury stop on the new Redwood Highway.
It quickly became a secluded retreat for Hollywood legends like Clark Gable and Spencer Tracy. But its old-world charm, antique-filled rooms, and location deep in the redwoods seem to retain more than just history.
Staff and guests have collected decades of paranormal reports, which the hotel itself shares. The third-floor west wing is the center of the activity, with frequent sightings of a “Lady in White,” believed to be a 1930s housekeeper, often seen with a child near the kitchen stairs.
Other guests report sherry decanters popping their tops, a broken grandfather clock chiming, and electrical anomalies, which some attribute to the playful spirit of co-founder Burtis Benbow, a “mechanical genius” who perhaps never left.
Amenities: Free WiFi, Outdoor pool, Restaurant, Golf course nearby.
Haunted Rating: 1 out of 5 Ghosts.
Best Time to Visit: Best visited during fall (Sept–Nov) for Avenue of the Giants foliage.
Find other Haunted Hotels in California By City
Find other Haunted Hotels in California By City
Click your city to find a Haunted Hotel near you.