Haunted Hotels in Eureka
Eureka’s 1 haunted accommodation channels the unique supernatural energy of its “Victorian Seaport” past, its opulent logging baron wealth, and the misty fog of Humboldt Bay. When you search for haunted hotels online or on Google Maps, you’ll find thousands of matching results, but we’ve meticulously reviewed every single one to create the most realistic, historically accurate collection of truly haunted hotels you can actually visit and stay in.
This property preserves spirits influenced by 19th-century lumber magnates, sailors lost at sea, and the staggering excess of the Carson Mansion era that makes Eureka’s hauntings unlike anywhere else. Discover coastal hauntings where Gilded Age fortunes meet the rugged, untamed redwood coast, creating the most architecturally stunning supernatural experiences in California.
Haunted stay options in Eureka, CA
Eagle House Victorian Inn (Inn at 2nd & C)
Address: 139 2nd Street, Eureka, CA 95501
Phone: (707) 443-4747
Website: historiceaglehouse.com
Price Range: Average rate: $150–$250 per night.
Notable Paranormal Signs: Shadow figures in hallways, disembodied whistling, doors slamming, voices mimicking staff, phantom footsteps.
History and Hauntings:
Built in 1888 by Finnish immigrants, this grand Victorian landmark originally served as the Eagle House, a high-end hotel for sailors, loggers, and affluent travelers arriving at Humboldt Bay.
After decades as a popular Italian restaurant and boarding house, it fell into disrepair before its full restoration. The building’s long history as a social hub for Old Town Eureka seems to have left a permanent impression.
Staff and guests report a building teeming with activity. The most prominent spirits are “Frank,” a former janitor and sailor seen in his uniform in the kitchen, and “Abagail,” a “lady of the manor” who allegedly slams stall doors and shatters lightbulbs in the downstairs women’s restroom.
The second floor is particularly active, with reports of a shadow man who darts from Room 214 and the violent rattling of the closet door in Room 215.
Amenities: Free WiFi, Restaurant, Bar/Lounge, Historic decor
Haunted Rating: 3 out of 5 Ghosts.
Best Time to Visit: Best visited during fall (Sept–Nov) for Victorian Halloween events in Eureka.
Find other Haunted Hotels in California By City
Find other Haunted Hotels in California By City
Click your city to find a Haunted Hotel near you.